The rule that comes before any recipe

Pickles look forgiving. Cucumbers, vinegar, salt, dill, a hot jar. That impression is exactly where home canners go wrong, because the safety of a shelf-stable pickle depends on how much acid ends up in every part of the jar, and you cannot see or taste that reliably.

The NCHFP general information on pickling, adapted from the USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning, puts it plainly. Do not alter vinegar, food, or water proportions in a recipe, and do not use a vinegar of unknown acidity. Use only recipes with tested proportions. There must be a minimum, uniform level of acid throughout the product to prevent the growth of botulinum bacteria.

That is why this page walks through one specific tested recipe, the USDA quick fresh-pack dill pickle, instead of offering a family formula or a tweaked version. Every amount and time below is copied from that page. If you want a different style, pick a different tested recipe from the same source; do not adjust this one. For the broader question of which foods need which canner, see our guide to pressure canning vs water bath canning. Pickles, with their added acid, belong in the boiling water canner.

What goes in the jar, measured the USDA way

The NCHFP ingredient list for one batch of quick fresh-pack dills reads as follows. It makes 7 to 9 pints.

**Cucumbers:** 8 pounds of 3- to 5-inch pickling cucumbers. **Soak:** 2 gallons of water and part of the salt. **Salt:** 1 1/4 cups canning or pickling salt in total, split into 3/4 cup for the soak and 1/2 cup for the brine. **Brine:** 1 1/2 quarts of vinegar at 5 percent acidity, 1/4 cup sugar and 2 quarts of water. **Spice:** 2 tablespoons whole mixed pickling spice, tied in a clean white cloth. **Per pint jar:** 1 teaspoon whole mustard seed and 1 1/2 heads of fresh dill, or 1 1/2 teaspoons of dill seed in place of the fresh heads.

One quirk is worth flagging. The ingredient line on the NCHFP page says about 3 tablespoons of mustard seed, '2 tsp to 1 tsp per pint jar', while the procedure says to add 1 teaspoon per pint. Mustard seed is a flavoring and not part of the acid balance, so the 1 teaspoon in the procedure is a safe reading. Do not stretch that same reasoning to the vinegar, water, salt or cucumbers.

The vinegar is the line you do not cross. NCHFP recommends white distilled or cider vinegar of 5 percent acidity (50 grain). White vinegar is usually preferred when a light color is wanted. The same page recommends canning or pickling salt, because the anti-caking material in other salts can cloud the brine, and it does not recommend flake salt because its density varies. NCHFP's salt page adds that iodized or non-iodized table salt can be used safely for pickles, with cloudy brine as the trade-off.

For the cucumbers, NCHFP's selection guide asks for firm fruit of the right size, about 4 inches for dills. It estimates an average of 9 pounds of cucumbers per canner load of 9 pints, and notes that a bushel weighs 48 pounds. Save odd-shaped or more mature cucumbers for relish or bread-and-butter pickles.

Quick fresh-pack dill pickles: processing time in a boiling water canner (raw pack)
Jar size0 to 1,000 ft1,001 to 6,000 ftAbove 6,000 ft
Pints10 min15 min20 min
Quarts15 min20 min25 min

Times from NCHFP Table 1 for this recipe only. Not a general pickle time; other recipes have their own tables.

Canning the pickles, step by step

The recipe steps come from the NCHFP quick fresh-pack page. The canner handling comes from the NCHFP page on using boiling water canners. Read both before you start, as NCHFP suggests, especially if this is your first time canning.

Step by step
  1. Wash them. Cut a 1/16-inch slice off the blossom end and discard it, but leave 1/4 inch of stem attached. NCHFP says blossoms may contain an enzyme that causes excessive softening.
  2. Dissolve 3/4 cup salt in 2 gallons of water, pour it over the cucumbers and let them stand 12 hours. Drain.
  3. Put the rack in the canner and fill it about half full of warm water for a load of pints. NCHFP says to preheat to 140 degrees F for raw-packed foods; these pickles are a raw pack.
  4. Combine the vinegar, 1/2 cup salt, sugar and 2 quarts water. Add the pickling spice tied in a clean white cloth. Heat to boiling.
  5. Fill jars with cucumbers. Add 1 teaspoon mustard seed and 1 1/2 heads fresh dill per pint. Cover with the boiling brine, leaving 1/2-inch headspace. Adjust lids.
  6. Load jars with a jar lifter, keeping them upright. Add boiling water so the level is at least 1 inch above the jar tops. Cover, bring to a vigorous boil, then start timing: 10 minutes for pints or 15 for quarts at 0 to 1,000 feet. If the boil stops, return to a full boil and restart the full time.
  7. Turn off the heat, remove the lid and wait 5 minutes. Lift jars onto a towel or rack with at least 1 inch between them. Leave them undisturbed 12 to 24 hours, then remove bands and check seals.

The crisper option: low-temperature pasteurization

The quick fresh-pack recipe allows one alternative to the boiling water process. NCHFP's low-temperature pasteurization treatment gives a better texture but must be carefully managed to avoid spoilage.

Place the jars in a canner filled halfway with warm water, 120 to 140 degrees F. Add hot water to 1 inch above the jars. Heat the water enough to hold 180 to 185 degrees F for 30 minutes, and check with a candy or jelly thermometer that it stays at least 180 degrees F the entire time. Temperatures above 185 degrees F may cause unnecessary softening.

NCHFP's caution is short: use this only when the recipe indicates. The quick fresh-pack dill page does indicate it. Many other pickle recipes do not, and the treatment is not a substitute for processing in general. If you cannot keep a thermometer in the water and watch it for half an hour, use the boiling water times in the table.

When pickles turn out soft, bitter or dark

Most pickle disappointments trace back to a handful of steps, and NCHFP's troubleshooting table for pickled foods lists them. For soft or slippery pickles it names vinegar that is too weak, too little brine to keep the cucumbers covered, pickles not processed properly, moldy garlic or spices, and blossom ends left on. The table's own caution comes first: if spoilage is evident, do not eat them. Vinegar that is too strong, spices cooked too long or salt substitutes containing potassium chloride can make pickles bitter.

Shriveling is linked to brine, syrup or vinegar that is too strong, and to overcooking or overprocessing; NCHFP's answer is to follow a reliable recipe exactly. Darkening can come from hard water, ground spices, spices left in the jar, iodized salt, or brass, iron, copper or zinc utensils. NCHFP's warning on that last point is firm: if brass, copper or zinc utensils and brining equipment were used, do not use the pickles. White sediment can come from salt with anti-caking agents.

Firmness tricks need care. NCHFP's general pickling page says alum does not improve the firmness of quick-process pickles, and that food-grade lime does firm cucumbers but the excess must be rinsed out through repeated soaks to make safe pickles. For this recipe the simpler route to crunch is the low-temperature treatment above.

If a lid does not seal or looks creased after cooling, our guide to why canning lids buckle covers what that means. NCHFP's canner instructions say to refrigerate unsealed jars and use them first.

Storing the finished jars

Once the jars have cooled 12 to 24 hours and sealed, remove the bands, wash the jars, and store them somewhere cool, dry and dark. The NCHFP troubleshooting table links spotted, dull or faded color to excessive light exposure, which is one more reason to keep them in a cupboard.

How long they keep depends on which kind of pickle you made. A boiling-water-processed jar like this one is shelf stable until opened; a quick refrigerator pickle that never went through a canner is a different product with a much shorter window. Our page on how long refrigerator pickles last sets the canned, fermented and refrigerator types side by side, and how long home canned food lasts covers the general one-year guidance for jars on the shelf.

Questions people ask

Can I use less vinegar or add water to make pickles less sour?

No. NCHFP tells home canners to keep the vinegar, food and water amounts exactly as tested, since evenly spread acid is what guards against botulism. For a milder taste, choose another tested recipe. Source: NCHFP pickling basics page.

How long do you water bath dill pickles?

For this USDA recipe, raw-packed pints get 10 minutes and quarts 15 minutes at up to 1,000 feet, with more time at higher elevations. Each other recipe lists separate times. Source: NCHFP quick dill recipe, Table 1.

Can I use table salt for canning pickles?

Yes. NCHFP says ordinary table salt, with or without iodine, is safe in both quick and fermented pickles, though additives may make the brine cloudy. Pickling salt remains the first choice. Source: NCHFP salt guidance.

Why are my canned pickles soft?

Usual suspects include weak vinegar, cucumbers poking above the brine, skipped processing, and blossom ends that were not trimmed. Discard any jar that shows spoilage. Source: NCHFP problems-with-pickles chart.

Sources

More in Canning & preserving