Give the jars time before you remake anything

A soft jar is not always a failed one. NCHFP's table of jelly and jam problems says some fruits take up to 2 weeks to set completely, and that plum jelly and jellies or jams made from bottled juices may take the longer time. It also says not to move jellied products for at least 12 hours after they are made.

If the jars are a few days old and sealed, keep them somewhere cool and dark and check again at the two-week mark. A remake means another round of heat. NCHFP's stiff jam page notes, about reheating thinned jam, that over-cooking pectin can reduce or destroy its ability to form a gel, so a remake is not guaranteed to set.

Why jelly stays soft

NCHFP lists eight causes of jelly that is too soft. Two of them, moving the jars early and not waiting long enough, need no remake at all. The other six happen at the stove, so the list is also useful before your next batch.

Causes of soft jelly and NCHFP's prevention advice
CauseWhat NCHFP says to do
Overcooking fruit to extract juiceAvoid it, because overcooking lowers the jellying capacity of pectin
Too much water to extract the juiceUse only the amount of water in the instructions
Wrong proportions of sugar and juiceFollow the recommended proportions
Undercooking, so the sugar is not concentrated enoughCook rapidly to the jellying point
Not enough acidLemon juice is sometimes added if the fruit is acid deficient
Batch too largeUse only 4 to 6 cups of juice in each batch of jelly
Moving the jars too soonDo not move jellied products for at least 12 hours
Not enough time before useSome fruits take up to 2 weeks to set up completely

Source: NCHFP, Causes and Possible Solutions for Problems with Jellied Fruit Products (adapted from So Easy to Preserve, 6th ed., 2014).

Pick a remaking method

The NCHFP remaking instructions come from the USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning. They are written for soft jellies, they use small batches, and they end with a fresh boiling water canner process. NCHFP asks you to read its boiling water canner instructions first. Which row you use depends on the pectin you have on hand.

The quantities below are NCHFP's published amounts for each quart of jelly. Measure your jelly and use the amounts exactly as listed for each quart, without adjusting them by eye.

Remaking one quart of soft jelly (NCHFP)
MethodMix inBoil
Powdered pectinStir ¼ cup sugar, ½ cup water, 2 tablespoons bottled lemon juice and 4 teaspoons powdered pectin together and bring to a boil, then add the jellyRolling boil over high heat, stirring constantly, then boil hard ½ minute
Liquid pectinBring the jelly alone to a boil, take it off the heat, then add ¾ cup sugar, 2 tablespoons bottled lemon juice and 2 tablespoons liquid pectinFull rolling boil, stirring constantly, then boil hard 1 minute
No added pectinAdd 2 tablespoons bottled lemon juice to the jellyHeat to boiling and boil 3 to 4 minutes, then test for doneness

Work with no more than 4 to 6 cups of jelly at a time.

Jar it and process it again

Canning treats remade jelly as a new batch, with sterile jars, new lids and a timed process. The guide to lid seals and processing explains why a closed lid cannot stand in for that step.

Step by step
  1. Take the pot off the heat as soon as the jelly is done and skim off the foam quickly.
  2. Fill sterile jars, leaving ¼ inch of headspace.
  3. Adjust new lids on the jars. Screw bands fingertip-tight only; overtightening during the boil can crease the lid without fixing a soft set.
  4. Process half-pint or pint jars in a boiling water canner for the time in the table, using your elevation. NCHFP gives no time for quart jars.
  5. Cool the jars undisturbed and test the seals as you would for any new batch.

Testing when the jelly has no added pectin

For the no-pectin row, the remaking page sends you to NCHFP's jelly doneness tests. The temperature test is the one NCHFP calls most dependable: use a candy or jelly thermometer, keep the bulb fully covered by jelly without touching the bottom of the pot, read it at eye level, and check the thermometer's accuracy in boiling water first.

The jelly is done at 8°F above the boiling point of water. That is 220°F at sea level, and NCHFP says to subtract 2°F for each 1,000 feet of elevation.

Two other tests exist. For the spoon or sheet test, dip a cool metal spoon into the boiling mixture and lift it out of the steam. The jellying point has been reached when two drops run together and sheet off the spoon. For the refrigerator or freezer test, put a little boiling jelly on a plate in the freezer compartment for a few minutes, with the pot off the heat meanwhile. If it gels, it should be done.

Temperature test by elevation (NCHFP)
ElevationJelly is done at
Sea level220°F
1,000 ft218°F
2,000 ft216°F
3,000 ft214°F
4,000 ft212°F
5,000 ft211°F
6,000 ft209°F
7,000 ft207°F
8,000 ft205°F

Soft is a texture problem, mold is not

NCHFP lists a soft set as a problem with causes you can correct. It labels mold or fermentation as spoilage and says not to use the product. In the same table, bubbles may denote spoilage, and if they are moving, the jar should not be used.

The NCHFP storage page for jams and jellies adds that if there is any mold on a jar of jam or jelly, or other signs of spoilage, you should discard the entire contents of the jar. In other words, do not scrape mold off and keep the rest. Before you remake anything, look the jar over. A jar with mold or moving bubbles goes in the trash, and the spoilage checklist for stored jars lists what else to look for.

The NCHFP pages cited here give three remaking methods. None of them uses gelatin, and none says what to do if a remade batch still stays soft.

Storing the remade jars

For best quality, NCHFP recommends using home-canned jams and jellies within a year, stored in a cool, dark, dry place (50 to 70°F), and refrigerating after opening. Its guidance covers properly processed jars from tested recipes and does not mention remade jelly separately. Lighter-colored products may darken sooner, which NCHFP treats as a quality issue and not a safety one.

Once a jar is open, NCHFP says to keep it in the refrigerator at 40°F or lower. Regular pectin-added, full-sugar cooked jams and jellies are best used within about a month of opening, and they may last longer depending on the product and how you handle it. Check an opened jar regularly, and discard the whole jar if you see mold or yeast or smell an off, fermented or alcohol odor. Keep the container closed and out of the warm kitchen between uses. For the difference between the canner types, see pressure canner versus water bath, and for which sources this site trusts, the food safety page. Opened tins bring up a storage question of their own, and the guide to opened cans covers whether the tin itself matters.

Questions people ask

How to fix runny jelly without pectin?

NCHFP's pectin-free remake uses 2 tablespoons of lemon juice (bottled) for each quart, then a 3 to 4 minute boil. Confirm the set with a thermometer, a cold spoon or a freezer plate, then jar and process the batch again. Keep each batch to 4 to 6 cups at most, then fill sterile jars with a quarter inch of space at the top, put on new lids, and give the jars (half-pints or pints) five, ten or fifteen minutes in the canner depending on elevation.

How long should I wait before deciding my jelly will not set?

For some fruits NCHFP allows as long as 2 weeks for a full set. Plum jelly, and anything made with store-bought juice, may need the longer end of that range, so hold off the full 2 weeks before deciding. Newly filled jars should sit untouched for the first half day.

Can I fix runny jelly with gelatin?

None of the NCHFP pages used here describe gelatin. The remaking methods NCHFP publishes are built on pectin in powder form, pectin in liquid form, or no added pectin at all, and every one of them calls for lemon juice from a bottle, so this guide does not cover gelatin.

Is runny jelly safe to eat?

A loose set is a quality problem. NCHFP says a typical jelly is safe to eat if the seal is intact and there are no visible signs of mold or yeast. Mold, or any fermentation, means spoilage, and a jar with bubbles that shift is not one to use. Throw the whole jar out in either case.

Do I need new lids when I remake jelly?

Yes. The instructions call for sterile jars and fresh lids. Processing in the boiling-water canner takes five, ten or fifteen minutes for jars of those two sizes, depending on whether you live at 1,000 feet or lower, up to 6,000 feet, or above that.

Sources

More in Canning & preserving